Colourant is just another ingredient in coolant. It may be used by manufacturers to make it easy to distinguish between different types, but it tells you exactly nothing about the composition. If for some reason in the past it had been decreed that all coolant be blue, then all the different formulas would now simply be blue.
Clean looking coolant only means that solids have been deposited, it may not mean that there aren't any. I make it a point to flush the system with running tap water before I put in new coolant. The radiator I take out and flush upside down, that helps dislodge deposits. The first flush water coming out is always a little cloudy, even after just 2 years.
The tester tells you only about frost protection, it doesn't say anything about the other ingredients like the important corrosion inhibitors. These have a limited lifespan and get less effective faster than the coolant will loose its frost protection. I don't even have a tester.
Renewing the coolant at the recommended interval is especially important on engines that combine an iron block with an alloy head (like our red blocks). Where different metals meet, electrolytic corrosion is always possible (as Land Rover Defender owners will tell you). I will not risk that for the relatively little effort and cost a coolant change entails.
One may argue that the car manufacturers recommendations were based on what was available at the time. If in the 1980s the best coolant had an expected lifespan of 2-3 years, you obviously won't find any recommendations exceeding that.
Does that make it right that you now use Zerex G-05 and make it last five years?
I don't know, but I do know that modern formulations may use ingredients that might not be very compatible with some materials used in the past. Or have more detergents that wash away deposits that were actually plugging (small) leaks...
Coolant is hardly "rocket science" so manufacturers like Valvoline come up with attention attracting packages and marketing and shout about special features and long life and so on. But look around on their websites and what do you see... texts like this:
Replace your antifreeze when recommended by your vehicle’s manufacturer to help minimize your risk of radiator failure and expensive repairs.
And to me, that's the one bit of advice definitely worth taking.
Long story short: drain the cooling system, flush, drain and fill with one specific brand and type of coolant. Repeat when Volvo recommends.
Since these old enigines have such a short (2 years) interval, I use the cheapest stuff I can find (€ 1,50/litre) and it has worked out fine for me for the past 11 years and 100,000 km.
|