Dear pierso,
Hope you're well. Any "tubing" - this term can refer to a range of materials, e.g., copper, steel, plastic, &c - for this repair needs to be purpose-made heater hose. Heater hose is made of rubber, compounded for long-term resistance to heat, and reinforced to stand-up to cooling system pressure. Thus, I'd definitely not use just any rubber hose. That is a recipe for disaster. With rubber products, there's no easy way to know what ingredients have been used, and how those ingredients have been processed. These factors make a huge difference in durability, etc. Thus, when it comes to heater hoses, use Volvo brand hoses.
I've replaced several sets of heater hoses, all factory original, that lasted about 15 years. The cars, on which I did this work, spent the first half of their lives in the southern part of the US, where average ambient temperatures are quite high. In a climate that on average is cooler (UK), heater hoses might last a bit longer. Even so, while the Volvo product is more costly, it brings peace-of-mind, especially if you've just done a headgasket.
A competent mechanic should have a test kit, to see if there are exhaust gases in the coolant. If so, the headgasket has failed. If not, then I'd do a compression test. The test for exhaust gases is simple and fast and should not cost a fortune. I'd have that done, before opting for a compression test.
It is possible that various anti-leak compounds have partly plugged the radiator, creating back-pressure, when the system is at operating temperature. I'd not use a stop-leak product for fear of plugging-up things other than where there's a leak. Thus, in a cooling system, I'd fear plugging-up the heater core, which is hard to access.
Based on several years' worth of reading posts on this Board, it seems that headgaskets want replacing at 250K miles (400K Kilometers), unless exceptional care has been taken. If a headgasket change is needed, I'd also replace the radiator, unless you're 100% sure (dated receipt with part described) the work has been done.
Hope this helps.
Yours faithfully,
Spook
|